Blog

Canada vs. Australia: Which Country is Better for Pakistani Immigrants?

In comparison of Canada & Australia as immigration destinations for Pakistani immigrants, both the countries offer excellent opportunities for students, families, and skilled workers. Both nations are ranked high in terms of their quality of life, economic stability, education, and healthcare but both have their unique immigration policies, job markets, and living conditions that may suit individuals in different ways. Below is the comprehensive comparison of Australia & Canada, focusing on several factors relevant to Pakistani immigrants.

1. Immigration Policies and Pathways

Canada:

• Express Entry System: Canada operates the Express Entry system for skilled immigrants, which uses a Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) to score applicants based on factors such as age, education, work experience, and language skills.
• Provincial Nominee Program (PNP): Provinces in Canada can nominate immigrants based on their specific labour market needs, which increases an applicant’s chances of being selected.
• Family Reunification: Canada has a robust family sponsorship program that allows permanent residents and citizens to bring family members, including spouses, children, parents, and grandparents.
• Clear and Predictable Process: Canada’s immigration system is known for being transparent and predictable, with published guidelines, points-based assessments, and regular draws for selection.

Australia:

• Skill Select System: Australia uses the Skill Select system, which is also points-based, to select immigrants based on their qualifications, English language ability, and work experience. The main visas include the Skilled Independent Visa (Subclass 189) and Skilled Nominated Visa (Subclass 190).
• Regional Focus: Australia encourages immigration to regional areas through the Skilled Work Regional Visa (Subclass 491), offering incentives such as a pathway to permanent residency after living and working in designated regional areas.
• Family Reunification: Australia also offers family visas, but the process can be slower and more restrictive compared to Canada, especially for parents and extended family members.

Verdict: Canada has a more flexible and transparent immigration system, particularly through the Express Entry and family reunification programs. Australia’s system is more region-focused, which may benefit those interested in living outside major cities.

2. Job Opportunities and Employment Market

Canada:

• High Demand for Skilled Workers: Canada has a strong demand for workers in sectors such as information technology, healthcare, engineering, construction, and skilled trades. The shortage of skilled labor is expected to grow, making it a welcoming market for skilled immigrants.
• Recognition of Foreign Credentials: While there is demand for skilled labor, Canada’s process for recognizing foreign qualifications can sometimes be lengthy and complicated, especially for regulated professions like medicine and engineering. However, Canada has been improving its credential recognition system for newcomers.
• Job Market Flexibility: Immigrants in Canada often face challenges in securing employment in their field of expertise upon arrival, but the overall employment rate for immigrants improves over time.

Australia:

• High Demand for Skilled Workers in Specific Sectors: Australia has a strong labour market for professionals in industries such as mining, healthcare, engineering, and IT. Australian employers frequently look for skilled migrants to fill gaps in these sectors, especially in regional areas.
• Fast Credential Recognition Process: Australia has a relatively efficient system for recognizing foreign qualifications, especially for skilled professionals like engineers, nurses, and tradespeople, helping skilled migrants integrate into the workforce faster.
• Employment Challenges in Cities: While the job market is strong in certain industries, finding employment in major cities like Sydney and Melbourne can be competitive, and skilled migrants may need to take lower-level jobs before securing roles in their fields.

Verdict: Both countries offer good job opportunities, but Australia is particularly attractive for quicker recognition of foreign qualifications. However, Canada may offer more flexibility and long-term growth opportunities, especially in industries like IT and healthcare.

3. Cost of Living and Housing

Canada:

• Moderate Cost of Living: The cost of living in Canada is generally considered moderate, but it can vary significantly depending on the city. For example, cities like Toronto and Vancouver have high housing costs, while smaller cities such as Calgary, Ottawa, and Halifax are more affordable.
• Affordable Housing Options: Canada offers affordable housing in many regions, especially in suburban and smaller cities, making it a feasible destination for new immigrants looking to settle in quieter areas with lower costs.
• Healthcare Costs: Canada offers free public healthcare to permanent residents and citizens, which significantly reduces out-of-pocket expenses.

Australia:

• Higher Cost of Living: The cost of living in Australia tends to be higher compared to Canada, especially in major cities like Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane. Housing, utilities, and groceries can be expensive in urban areas.
• Expensive Housing: Australia’s housing market is known for high prices, especially in metropolitan cities. However, more affordable housing is available in regional areas, which the government is encouraging skilled migrants to explore.
• Healthcare Costs: Australia has a public healthcare system called Medicare, but many residents also opt for private health insurance to cover additional costs not included in the public system. Medicare covers essential medical services, but some treatments may require out-of-pocket payments or insurance.

Verdict: Canada generally has a more affordable cost of living, particularly outside major urban centres. Australia offers high living standards but tends to have higher costs, particularly in housing.

4. Education System

Canada:

• World-Class Education System: Canada offers a highly regarded education system, with free public education available for children of immigrants up to secondary school. Canadian universities are globally ranked, offering world-class education at relatively affordable costs compared to the U.S. or U.K.
• Pathways for International Students: Canada is also a popular destination for international students, and many Pakistani students pursue higher education in Canada due to the post-graduation work opportunities and pathways to permanent residency.

Australia:

• Renowned for Higher Education: Australia also has a world-class education system, especially at the tertiary level. Universities in Australia, such as the University of Melbourne, University of Sydney, and Australian National University, are internationally recognized.
• Public Education System: Australia provides free or low-cost public education for children of residents and citizens. International students also benefit from strong support systems and pathways to permanent residency after graduation.

Verdict: Both Canada and Australia offer excellent education systems, but Canada may provide more affordable options for families and students at the primary and secondary levels, with easier pathways for international students to stay permanently.

5. Cultural and Social Integration

Canada:

• Multicultural Society: Canada is known for its multicultural and immigrant-friendly society. Cities like Toronto, Vancouver, and Calgary have large Pakistani and South Asian communities, which makes it easier for newcomers to integrate.
• Supportive Government Policies: Canada actively promotes diversity and inclusion, offering various settlement services, language training programs, and support systems for new immigrants.

Australia:

• Cultural Diversity: Australia also has a diverse and multicultural society, with strong South Asian communities in cities like Melbourne and Sydney. The country celebrates its immigrant population, but integration can be slower in more regional areas.
• Immigration Sentiment: While Australia welcomes skilled immigrants, there have been occasional public debates about immigration levels, especially around asylum seekers. However, overall, the country remains welcoming to skilled immigrants.

Verdict: Canada may offer a slightly more immigrant-friendly environment with strong support for integration and established Pakistani communities in many major cities.

6. Climate and Geography

Canada:

• Cold Winters: Canada is known for its harsh winters, particularly in the northern provinces. Cities like Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver experience snowy, cold winters, although Vancouver has a milder climate compared to other parts of the country.
• Beautiful Landscapes: Canada is home to stunning landscapes, including forests, lakes, and mountains, offering various outdoor recreational activities.

Australia:

• Warm Climate: Australia enjoys a warm, temperate climate, especially in coastal areas. Winters are mild compared to Canada, making Australia an attractive destination for those who prefer warmer weather.
• Outdoor Lifestyle: Australia is known for its beaches, national parks, and outdoor lifestyle, making it ideal for those who enjoy outdoor activities and a more laid-back lifestyle.

Verdict: Australia offers a more favourable climate, especially for those who prefer warmer weather, while Canada is better suited for those who don’t mind cold winters and enjoy diverse seasons.

Conclusion: Which Country is Better for Pakistani Immigrants?

• For Skilled Immigration and Job Opportunities: Australia may offer faster recognition of foreign qualifications and specific regional job opportunities, but Canada offers a more flexible, transparent immigration system and long-term job market potential.
• For Families and Education: Canada provides more affordable living and education options, along with better family reunification programs, making it a better choice for immigrants with families.
• For Climate and Lifestyle: Australia has the advantage of a warm climate and outdoor lifestyle, but Canada offers a more established multicultural society and support for new immigrants.

In summary, Canada may be a better choice for Pakistani immigrants seeking family-friendly immigration policies, affordable living, and a multicultural society, while Australia might be better for those who prioritize quick employment in regional areas, faster credential recognition, and a warmer climate. Both countries are excellent choices depending on individual priorities.